Thursday, November 5, 2026

Is it art? You decide!

 Modern Art is such a polarizing thing. I think sometimes the artists create things just to get a gut punch emotional reaction out of us viewers, and not always in the good sense. Bilbao is home to the Guggenheim Bilbao museum of Modern Art, and it is the number one thing to visit on anybody's list of things to visit in this city. Now, if you have been a follower of this blog for any length of time, you know that Mario and I have a love/hate relationship with Modern Art. For the most part, we dislike the art and how we never understand the artists' deeper meanings, but we love to mock it, and I think that's why we like to torture ourselves with visits to museums devoted to the stuff. Yes, there is plenty of interesting, thought provoking art out there, but most of it is toilets gilded in Prada packaging or paintings made by naked bodies being rolled around on a canvas, with meanings so deep that I swear the artists had to use a shovel to dig them up. But, ART! So here we find ourselves, face-to-face with the majesty of Frank Gehry's flower bouquet of a building, ready for whatever is about to happen. Care to join in? Come play a game of Is it art? with us!

View from the neighbouring bridge down to the Guggenheim museum in all of its glory. You can get a good look at the fins fanning out from the centre "bouquet" of the building. Is it meant to look like a bouquet? Maybe - that's what I saw when I looked at an aerial view of it. Check out the big spider sculpture in the foreground. For anyone familiar with the Ottawa area, does it look familiar?


Maman, a spider sculpture by artist Louise Bourgeois(1999), with a sac of white marble eggs nestled in its belly, stands 9 metres tall. There is a similar sculpture outside the National Gallery of Canada, in Ottawa, which is a bronze casting(like this one) of the original that lived at the Tate Modern once upon a time. We walked under it, and so did everyone else. 
Also on our approach the museum, this fuzzy fellow stood to greet us. Puppy, by Jeff Koons, is a giant topiary that was supposed to be a temporary installment, hence the real flowers, but the people of Bilbao loved it so much, the museum made is permanent...and changes the flowers twice a year! You might recognize the name - Jeff Koons is the same artist who created the bright mylar balloon dog sculptures. Trust me - you've seen those before. 


The grand atrium as you enter the Guggenheim is impressive, and a little confusing at the same time. The curves are gorgeous, but make navigating the museum a really challenge.
One massive gallery houses 8(eight!) giant weathering steel sculptures by artist Richard Serra, titled The Matter of Time. This was an impressive installment. 


Giant 10 ton curved steel plates are place to create different forms which we as viewers are meant to interact with, thus transforming us into the subject of the art instead. 
The plates curl, spiral, lean in or push out, creating these canyons, rooms, corridors, tunnels, mazes in which we can adventure. 


The effect was palpable, often playing on our sense of balance while we navigated a leaning spiral, or creating sound tunnels that echoed every noise, every whisper across the whole gallery. 
So, what do you think Mario did? Starting whistling the theme to the Lost Woods from Legend of Zelda : Ocarina of Time while winding through the echo chamber spirals. I don't know if anyone else got the reference, but we were enjoying ourselves!


Rising Sea, by El Anatsui, does a pretty good job of getting the message across. You can clearly see the tops of building along the lower extremity of the piece, and the giant, rumpled wave advancing towards them ready to crash. 
Take a few steps closer, and you can see the details of the giant curtain. It is made of crushes metal bottle caps, all stitched together using tiny loops of copper. The artist is of Ghanaian descent, and is know to use traditional African art forms to create his pieces, including incorporating post-consumer materials like strips of bottle cap seals or evaporated milk cans.


Installation for Bilbao, by Jenny Holzer. LED strips that light up on both sides, displaying one line "Truisms" in several languages, hide in a corner of the Atrium, surrounded by super-reflective walls. The messages scrolling were a bit rough and sometimes vulgar, and often the strips were flashing like strobe lights - the whole just gave me a headache rather than conveyed a message that I was willing to stick around to receive.
I had high hopes for this : Yayoi Kusama's Infinity Mirrored Room - A Wish for Human Happiness Calling From Beyond the Universe. I have seen many of these infinity room exhibits advertised, and they always looks so immersive, so beautiful, and even this photo gives that impression, but the reality is very far off. The exhibit is a 16x20 white box, that you enter into to be surrounded by mirrors and bright lights that are reflected times infinity. Except the museum, knowing this is a popular exhibit, are controlling access, and sending people through the room - in small groups. This creates a much more crowded environment, and also the reflections of a multitude of people inside the same space. I found it just about ruined the "emmersiveness" of the room. Add this one to the list of Instagram gimmicks and we'll move on.


 
James Rosenquist's The Swimmer in the Econo-mist(painting 2) is just a beautiful piece to behold. Tell me - how does someone paint a blurry effect?! This reminded me of a lot of the pop-art style and colour used at the Omega Mart at Meow Wolf Las Vegas. Maybe there is some inspiration drawn from Rosenquist? Either way, this was cool, even though it spoke nothing more to me than how much washing up I would be doing when I got home from this trip!

There were so many more pieces that elicited feeling of confusion, disgust, or annoyance, that did not encourage my photo-taking in any way, nor a willingness to even pause and give the painting/sculpture a second look. I am reminded of the canvas painted by dragging around naked bodies - and finding out the fact that it was done LIVE at the museum, as some sort of performance art, and that turned me off of the resulting canvas even more! Thankfully, the whole second floor was being renovated to house some new exhibits and was off-limits, so back outside we went. 

One last piece, or should I say two: The juxtaposition of these two sculptures just seemed so perfect that I cannot believe this was not intentional.

Finding art in the everyday : Lunch was a 3 course menu del dia, and I could not believe how even my chickpeas and chorizo lined up so perfectly to make this dish more beautiful that some of the art in the Guggenheim!  
Walking along the river, we discovered lounge chairs that were all occupied except for one, because the beauty of the sun and accompanying 21-degree temperature was enough to get everyone outside.

Sometime beauty can be a simple as a conversation in the sun along the riverfront. And how the sunlight can light up those mountains so perfectly.
And beauty can be found in the draw of a sun-lit passageway, leading to a plaza where there is a delicious afternoon coffee to be had. Now, is that art? 


If you ask me, the more you have to explain why your art is art, the less I want to see it. I don't want an instruction manual, or an essay about why a loincloth made up of stuffed animals is actually the artist's expression of disappointment that Santa did not bring him new hockey skates when he was 7, I just want to see what the artist sees, and make up my own mind as to what it means.

My final piece? The Sun has Set over Bilbao, fueled by a cold glass of Fanta and the tiredness that comes from a day of walking all over the city, and perhaps a too-salty piece of grilled Bass at lunch.

Is it art? You decide!

No comments:

Post a Comment